Why Browsers Haven't Standardized
 
SEARCH: webmonkey  the web

 
Commentary
-------------------------
Print
this article for free. 
-------------------------

Pages:
1  Why Browsers Haven't Standardized
2 Browser Companies Aren't Really Out to Get You
3 It Can't Be That Bad, Can It?
4 New Rules!
5 Decisions, Decisions
6 Wait and See
7 The Answer's Out There

Why Browsers Haven't Standardized
by Eric Meyer 22 September 1998

Eric Meyer [an error occurred while processing this directive]is the hypermedia systems manager for Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio, which is much nicer than you've been led to believe. His wife Kat claims that he never makes any on-line references to her.

Page 1

It's a familiar scenario. A new version of a Web browser is released, and while it has all the expected improvements and updates to existing features like HTML, CSS, and other open standards, it also has a number of new, and wholly proprietary, features: previously unknown style properties or HTML-like tags, even entirely new technologies undescribed in any specification.

To the untrained eye, these puzzling additions are viewed as an unnecessary and irritating detour. Once again, the browser company has zipped off into the weeds, totally ignoring standards in an attempt to develop the next "killer app" to take over the Web and crush the competition. And before the end of the first day of a browser's release, cries of outrage echo through the Web community.

Why, people complain, do browser companies continue to forge blindly ahead with more and more new features when they haven't even implemented existing standards correctly? For example, both Microsoft and Netscape are promising support for CSS2 when they haven't even gotten CSS1 right. Both companies also claim they'll offer full support for XML, yet they don't even have matching HTML parsers (depending on who you ask, they may not even have HTML parsers at all). What's the deal? Why can't these bozos follow the standards process? What do they think it's there for, anyway?

These complaints have prompted a major grassroots campaign, the Web Standards Project (WSP), formed for the sole purpose of demanding standards compliance in all Web browsers. But, as with many aspects of life, things aren't as simple as they first appear.

next page»